Indefensible– ND Senate Upholds Veto on Bill Prohibiting Transgenders in Girls’ Sports

Senator Kristin Roers (R - District 27) urges colleagues to defeat a ban on transgenders in girls' sports. (Photo via screenshot.)

After a long and controversial road for House Bill 1298, it’s dead. Though it gained the necessary 2/3 vote in the House to override Governor Doug Burgum’s veto, the Senate failed to do so— by four votes.

As you’re likely aware, HB 1298 sought to prohibit biological males — who identify as females — from participating in girls’ sports. To me, the concept isn’t exactly complicated. Any rational person understands the fundamental biological differences between males and females.

Unfortunately, rationale doesn’t always prevail in politics. In fact, these days it might be argued that, more often than not, it doesn’t. And that’s what we saw with this bill.

Opponents to the ban paraded out a variety of arguments. Prevalent among them was fear of potential lawsuits and essentially labeling those who supported the legislation as hateful and discriminatory. Yet, despite the exceptional counterarguments of someone like Senator Doug Larsen (R – District 34), logic and reason simply didn’t matter to some of his colleagues.

Just how indefensible is it that the bill didn’t become law? Let me illustrate.

Hypothetical A

Suppose 16-year old John Doe — who is an average track athlete — decides he wants to run with the girls’ track team. Not because he thinks he’s a girl, but because he realizes he’ll blow away the competition.

Would he be permitted to make the switch? You and I both know the answer— No! Nor should he be. And for obvious reasons. No rational person would support such a thing. Which is why nobody advocates for it happening.

Hypothetical B

Now, let’s suppose John claims he’s a girl. True, he’s biologically a male. He knows this. But he’s also felt for a while now that he should have been female. In fact, he’s so convinced — as are his parents — that he’s been undergoing testosterone-suppression treatment for the last year in an effort to “transition”.

Under these latter conditions, and according to the current policy of the North Dakota High School Activities Association — the same one cited by Governor Burgum in his veto — John is free to join the girls’ track team.

It’s ludicrous.

In December of last year, the British Journal of Sports Medicine released its findings in a study indicating “that while hormone treatment was associated with changes in athletic performance, transgender women still retained a competitive advantage 2 years later.” In fact, on average, they were still “12% faster than other women.” (Emphasis Added)

Is it any wonder why Senator Michael Dwyer (R – District 47) expressed more than once how flawed the NDHSAA policy is?

The fundamental reason we even have girls’ sports in the first place is because girls are biologically very different from boys. In my mind, that’s so obvious it’s not even really debatable. Whether we’re talking skeletal and muscular systems or a variety of other characteristics, boys are generally bigger, faster, and stronger.

Governor Burgum’s veto — and the subsequent failure of the Senate to override it — is indefensible.

Sources:

  1. North Dakota Bill Versions: HB 1298 (nd.gov)
  2. North Dakota Bill Actions: HB 1298 (nd.gov)
  3. ND governor vetoes ‘Transgender Sports’ bill (valleynewslive.com)
  4. North Dakota Legislative Branch Video (nd.gov)
  5. Untitled (ndhsaa.com)
  6. House of Rep Daily Journal – Date 04-22-2021 Day 71 (nd.gov)
  7. Current treatment period may be too short to remove competitive advantage of transgender athletes: 12 months is period proposed by World Athletics and International Olympics Committee — ScienceDaily
  8. North Dakota Bill Video: HB 1298 (nd.gov)
Facebook Comments

Donate to The Minuteman Blog

Your donations are greatly appreciated. Thank You.


  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Litecoin
Scan to Donate Bitcoin to 36qWjsnKSfQRUbDDc5XMqwkvaJZQuLBqwR

Donate Bitcoin to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Bitcoin

Scan to Donate Ethereum to 0x9966c92Bb9534E919af2524234594ff428D7D161

Donate Ethereum to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Ethereum

Scan to Donate Litecoin to MNMSABX9BVxgPj1WZ2Z7kj8bzqzYaFU5FG

Donate Litecoin to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Litecoin


About T. Arthur Mason 859 Articles
T. Arthur Mason is a native North Dakotan who has spent nearly all of his life in the Peace Garden State. As the third of four children in Western North Dakota, Mason grew to appreciate family and the outdoors. Some of his fondest memories are annual deer hunts with family and friends. In his early teenage years, faith became a central part of T. Arthur Mason's life. He and the majority of his family attend church together on a weekly basis and find this a fulfilling aspect of their lives. Through the influence of his father, T. Arthur Mason became intrigued with politics. As a boy, he attended political events with his father and enjoyed the friendships that resulted as a byproduct of those political associations. As Mason grew older, he became convinced that the quote often attributed to Thomas Jefferson was true, "That government is best which governs least." Today, T. Arthur Mason enjoys time with his wife and children, an occasional hunt, and an increasingly active life on the political scene. This blog is the fulfillment of a dream to design a web site in the realm of politics and to advocate for the principles of Liberty and constitutionally limited government. On behalf of all those that contribute to The Minuteman, we hope you enjoy your time on the site and will share the message with others.